Give the gift of LIFE! Support the Population Research Institute!


Mexico City Policy Under Fire

The Mexico City Policy is under fire in Congress…again.

In June, the House of Representatives, at the instigation of Congresswoman Nita Lowey (D-NY) voted 223–201 to pass a bill seeking to gut the Mexico City Policy.

A Little Background on the Mexico City Policy

This Reagan-era policy prohibits American tax dollars from going to abortion- performing organizations in other countries. Pro-abortion organizations, which have lost hundreds of millions of dollars on account of this restriction, bitterly refer to Mexico City Policy as the “global gag rule.” They have fought against it from its inception in 1984.

The new assault is deceptive. While not deleting the prohibition on federal funds going to organizations that provide abortions, the rewritten provision would allow family planning groups to receive what are called “in-kind commodities,” instead. Tens of millions of dollars of pills, condoms, Norplant, and Depo-Provera would be shipped to IPPF and other pro-abortion groups.

Strange Falsehoods: “Making Abortion More Rare”

Congresswoman Nita Lowey, who introduced the amendment, claims that “This amendment would advance the Bush administrations stated goal of the Mexico City policy to ‘make abortion more rate,’ and protect women and children. It is simply not enough to say you support family planning, so long as the current restrictions remain in law.”

Contraception always leads to abortion, of course, so Lowey’s argument is false on its face.

And won’t giving subsidies to pro-abortion groups empower them to promote and perform more abortions? Of course it will.

As Congressman Chris Smith pointed out, giving freebies to abortion groups is effectively the same thing as giving them funding.

If we provide either cash or in-kind contributions to abortion organizations, we empower them and we enable them to campaign to expand abortion,

Smith said in an impassioned speech on the House floor.

He continued:

If protecting babies and women from abortion matters to you… there is no way that any of us could work to overturn the Mexico City Policy. This is the time to stand for the inconvenient ones who can’t speak for themselves.


Still, despite determined opposition from the House Pro-life Caucus, led by Smith, the Lowey amendment passed the House. The Senate has not yet taken up the amendment, but it is expected to pass there as well.

The good news is that Bush has promised to veto the amendment if it reaches his desk, and there are enough votes in the House and Senate to sustain a veto.

Pro-Lifers Must Act

But pro-lifers cannot be complacent. The war in Iraq and the immigration issue receive the lion’s share of the President’s attention these days, so we must continue to raise pro-life issues lest a distracted White House misjudge their importance.

Clever amendments like Lowey’s are dangerous to our cause. While the Freedom of Choice Act was more of a publicity stunt than anything else, this stealth attack on the Mexico City Policy provides wishy-washy politicians with a cover story They can cast a pro-abortion vote on the grounds that they are ostensibly “helping to reduce the number of abortion is.”

Smith is Correct

Congressman Chris Smith is right: giving commodities to abortion-providers is the same thing as giving them funds.

We must not support abortion abroad—or at home—with American tax dollars.

Comments are closed on this post.

Recent Posts

Never miss an update!

Get our Weekly Briefing! We send out a well-researched, in-depth article on a variety of topics once a week, to large and growing English-speaking and Spanish-speaking audiences.